SysAid. performance. If you want to check or understand better our results, in this appendix we provide details on the data, the equipment, and the software we used. Unless stated otherwise, default settings should be used. It is important to keep in mind particularly in the Linux/open-source space there can be vastly different OS configurations, with this overview intended to offer just general guidance as to the performance expectations. The profile data contain gender, age, hobbies, interest, education, etc. The database was first created by sequentially inserting all the 1 B keys. Before building RocksDB with AES-256 support, users need to build and install the IPP-Crypto library. A separate thread issues writes to the database at its best effort. To run this test with the Phoronix Test Suite, the basic command is: phoronix-test-suite benchmark rocksdb. At this moment, I do notknow what causes these drops. 4.5M - 7M read QPS for point lookups with sustained writes. -- ZenFS To setup ZenFS on a NVMe ZNS device, follow the instructions here. Details on ZippyDB are in Muthu Annamalais talk at Data@Scale in Seattle. Begin by resetting your BIOS to default setting, then follow the suggestion below for changes: Advanced/Power & Performance/CPU Power and Performance Policy. Optimized for Fast Storage For a detailed look at how MyRocks stacks up against typical InnoDB deployments, read my blog MyRocks Engine: Things to Know Before You Start. The Facebook-MyRocks engineering team also provided me input on the best settings for MyRocks. Wrapping my head around the JSON notation is for sure not impossible but boy can querying data be complicated. MyRocks is the RocksDB based storage engine for MySQL. To avoid this condition, increase the maximum open files to at least 500000. We are open sourcing this project on GitHub because we think it will be useful beyond Facebook. The performance results in section 5.2 of the paper ZNS: Avoiding the Block Interface Tax for Flash-based SSDs endobj rocksdb is configured to avoid compactions triggered by seeks whereas leveldb does seek-compaction for this workload. then RocksDB is a great high-performance data-modeling base (it's not relational how-ever) It's more like a . He also co-authored the book High Performance MySQL: Optimization, Backups, and Replication 3rd Edition. The section above describes the tests we performed with each database system. I set innodb_buffer_pool_size in the script running benchmark, For all the configuration parameters that are recommended for the six workloads, we assume a memory size of 256GB to be available for use. The reported time does not include data loading phase. Here are the commands used to run the benchmark with leveldb: A tag already exists with the provided branch name. First, a simple distinct lookup of the neighbors of neighbors and second the distinct neighbors of neighbors with the full profile data. This was the first test related to the network use case. x] TS-j[+:aZk-jN)Z{Zik+ -VE3*20&2OaA0v !$ []'{o=W000000000-\h-6%OyMZZZX`|gGuPxua}9s%&&knCr]t|}b1yVZ_B. RocksDB can easily write at the top speed supported by SSD because it is write optimized. Vadim Tkachenko co-founded Percona in 2006 and serves as its Chief Technology Officer. There were 32 threads in the benchmark application issuing random reads to the database. We experienced the same. Very helpful for me. Below is an overview of the generalized performance for components where there is sufficient statistically significant data based upon user-uploaded results. All rights reserved. Single Document Reads (100,000 different documents) By signing in, you agree to our Terms of Service. To get a consistent performance result, we recommend users to follow a chosen sequence of running the workloads and stick with it. %PDF-1.5 Computing the aggregation is efficient in ArangoDB, taking on an average of 1.07 seconds and defining the baseline. Data was first loaded into the database by sequentially writing all the 1B keys to the database. RocksDB Advisor is a command-line tool that can be used to assist in finding optimal configuration parameters[2]. In this benchmark we could show again, that ArangoDB can compete with the leading single-model database systems on their home turf. Do you work for Intel? files into zones on a raw zoned block device. After that, there is no reason to add more memory. RocksDB is adaptable to different workloads. Basically, MyRocks performs as expected for a write-optimized engine. Here are the command(s) for loading the data into rocksdb. endobj as GitHub blocks most GitHub Wikis from search engines. One hidden danger with LSM (rocksDB) is that you may not be catching all the more extreme edgecases of compactions with a test that only lasts for 1 hr. The quickest way to understand boxplots is to take a look at the middle line. Friendships in Pokec are directed. See the Project Site for more information. No other indexes were used. Comparing TokuDB, RocksDB and InnoDB Performance - MinervaDB Rocksdb was configured to use multi-threaded compactions so that multiple threads could be simultaneously compacting (via file-renames) non-overlapping key ranges in multiple levels. can be replicated by using the rocksdb_block_cache_size controls the size of how much memory RocksDB is using to cache data on the read path. MyRocks does not require a lot of memory and shows constant write IO while using most of the CPU resources. sysbench is a scriptable multi-threaded benchmark tool based on LuaJIT. It is most frequently used for database benchmarks, but can also be used to create arbitrarily complex workloads that do not involve a database server. We measured the performance of Redmine on MyRocks, Facebook's build of MySQL, with RocksDB as a storage engine and compared it with the performance of other servers (original MySQL 5.6 and MariaDB 10.1) using InnoDB as the storage engine. Subscribe now and we'll send you an update every Friday at 1pm ET. RocksDB VS Databricks Compare RocksDB VS Databricks and see what are their differences. Results for single-reads and single-writes were slightly better with the old NodeJS version, but with no effect on the overall ranking. LiteDB and RocksDB can be categorized as "Databases" tools. The test is done using rocksdb release 2.7 and leveldb 1.15. ArangoDB, as a native multi-model database, competes with many single-model storage technologies. Since MongoDB treats edges just as documents in another collection, we helped it a bit for the graph queries by creating two more indexes on the _from and _to attributes of the friendship relation. The reported time does not include data loading phase. We used PostgreSQL with the user profiles stored in a table with two columns, the Profile ID and a JSONB data type for the whole profile data. The performance of RocksDB is contingent on its tuning. This is a typical graph matching problem, considering paths of length one or two. rendering errors, broken links, and missing images. Traditionally I use R with ggplot2. For example, you can configure RocksDB to provide extremely low query latency on terabytes of data. Here you increased block cache size and discovered that it didnt affect write performance because block cache is only used for read path. //PDF RocksDB* db bench Tuning Guide on 3rd Generation Intel Xeon Scalable The system is configured to store transaction logs on persistent storage so that data is not lost on machine reboots. RocksDB builds on LevelDB to be scalable to run on servers with many CPU cores, to efficiently use fast storage, to support IO-bound, in-memory and write-once workloads, and to be flexible to allow for innovation. We go over the differences, major and minor, in the storage engine and discuss its implementation with Percona Server. The shortest path query was not tested for MongoDB or PostgreSQL since those queries would have had to be implemented completely on the client side for those database systems. No product or component can be absolutely secure. Great article. In this test, a key prefix size of 12 bytes is indexed (i.e. The first point is obvious: the golden rule of a useful benchmark is to only compare apples and apples. We benchmarked LevelDB and found that it was unsuitable for our server workloads. RocksDB uses LSM tree that grows in size as more data is added to a database. Measure performance to randomly overwrite 2 billion keys into the database. Therefore, we have published all of the scripts necessary for anyone to repeat this benchmark with minimum effort. Based on OpenBenchmarking.org data, the selected test / test configuration (Facebook RocksDB 6.22.1 - Test: Sequential Fill) has an average run-time of 7 minutes. Of course, performing our own benchmark can be questionable. How large was this memory area in your experiments? Sign in here. We made sure for each experiment that the database had a chance to load all relevant data into RAM. Pitfalls and misconceptions. Please note that as the stats for MongoDB worsened significantly in comparison to what we measured in 2015, we reran the test for MongoDB with the same NodeJS version that we used in the 2015 benchmark. To run any of the db_bench workloads described in sections 3.3.1 to 3.3.6 with encryption support, four new configuration parameters need to be added and set. As PostGreSQL starts per default with a main memory limit of only 128MB, we used a PostgreSQL tuning configurator to provide fair conditions for everyone. RocksDB is a high performance embedded database for key-value data. rocksdb is configured to verify checksums on every read while leveldb has checksum verification switched off. RocksDB is natively designed to give high-end performance for fast storage and server workloads. We didnt use a secondary index for this attribute on any of the databases so that they all have to perform a full-collection scan and do a counting statistics this is a typical ad-hoc query. Embedded Typed Readonly In-Memory Document Database for .NET Core and Unity. RocksDB builds on LevelDB to be scalable to run on servers with many CPU cores, to efficiently use fast storage, to support IO-bound, in-memory and write-once workloads, and to be flexible to allow for innovation. GitHub blocks most GitHub Wikis from search engines. However, behavior of scanning beyond the prefix boundary is not defined. Your email address will not be published. Keys and values are just arbitrarily-sized byte streams. Thank you for running it again in 2018 with variance included. more CData: Connect to Big Data & NoSQL through standard Drivers. It provides maximum throughput for point lookup queries. This is a benchmark of Facebook's RocksDB as an embeddable persistent key-value store for fast storage based on Google's LevelDB. For MyRocks we will use LZ4 as the default compression on disk. Learn more atwww.Intel.com/PerformanceIndex. We received feedback from previous benchmarks that for a real use case we need to return more than IDs. We would also like to engage with the academic community on topics related to efficiency for modern database algorithms. This is a fairly common access pattern for graph data. In the Readwhilewriting benchmark, writing uses a single thread to PUT data into the database and read the database concurrently. more: Speedb: A high performance RocksDB-compliant key-value store optimized for write-intensive workloads. . For the tests, we used the Pokec dataset provided by the Stanford University SNAP. Data is first loaded into the database by sequentially writing all 8B keys to the database. Notable instruction set extensions supported by this test, based on an automatic analysis by the Phoronix Test Suite / OpenBenchmarking.org analytics engine. I wanted to take a moment to share our journey to 1.0 and the road ahead. Try it today! Finding Neighbors and Neighbors of Neighbors (distinct, for 1,000 vertices) For this test we proceed similarly: We loaded 100,000 different documents into the node.js client and then measured the wallclock time needed to send all of them to the database, using individual queries. We used the following Community Editions and driver versions: All databases were installed on the same machine. With the most default settings I saw stalls even during 1 hour runs. To prove that we are meeting our goals and are competitive, we run and publish occasionally an update to the benchmark series. SQLite 2.7.6 is significantly faster (sometimes as much as 10 or 20 times faster) than the default PostgreSQL 7.1.3 installation on RedHat 7.2 for most common operations. We start by covering MyRocks and its architecture, use cases of MyRocks, and demonstrate our benchmarking results, so you can determine if the MyRocks storage engine can help you get increased performance for your workload. Rockset stores its indexes on RocksDB. This is a pure graph test with a query that is particularly suited for a graph database. Please note that if you are doing the benchmark yourself and OrientDB takes more than three hours to import the data, dont panic. endobj <>>> Furthermore, we adapted community and vendor provided configuration parameters from Michael Hunger of Neo4j and Luca Garulli of OrientDB to improve individual settings. Here are the details of the test setup: Instance type: i3.8xlarge 32 vCPUs reported, Intel Xeo E5-2686 v4 (Broadwell) @ 2.3GHz You can refer to my article How Three Fundamental Data Structures Impact Storage and Retrieval for more details. The indexable preview below may have endobj Amsterdam, North Holland, Netherlands' Internet Speeds Leveldb is very slow because of high write amplification. RocksDB is forked from LevelDB, which was developed by Google to exploit the best performance of many CPU cores as well as fast storage like SSD for I/O bound workloads. RocksDB VS Hazelcast - compare differences & reviews? The complete set of 853,000 profiles (1,000 vertices) would have been too much for nodejs. ArangoDB is twice as fast as Neo4j and over one-hundred times faster than OrientDB. In Neo4j, the attribute values of the profile documents are stored as properties of the vertices. I think this potentially makes MyRocks a great choice for cloud database instances, where both memory and IO can cost a lot. RocksDB is a key-value store and is a foundational piece of the CockroachDB architecture. Throughput variation is something to be concerned about, but I hope this getsimproved in the future. The algorithm searches for the shortest distance between a start vertex and an end vertex. Files were configured to be 64 MB in size so that frequent fsyncs after creation of newly compacted files are reduced. Synap. RocksDB In Memory Workload Performance Benchmarks - facebook/rocksdb Percona Labs designs no-gimmick tests of hardware, filesystems, storage engines, and databases that surpass the standard performance and functionality scenario benchmarks. // Your costs and results may vary. ArangoDB loses a bit in single-writes and single-reads, but achieves nonetheless an acceptable overall performance. Here are the commands to overwrite 2 billion keys in rocksdb: Measure random read performance of a database with 1 Billion keys, each key is 10 bytes and value is 800 bytes. Also: 2018? pts/rocksdb-1.0.0 [View Source] Tue, 08 Oct 2019 18:48:16 GMTInitial commit of Facebook RocksDB benchmark. I would be curious to see 8.0 results for InnoDB there were some redo log enhancements that made it in shortly before GA. looks good. The task for this test was to find 1,000 shortest paths in a highly connected social network to answer the question how close two persons are in the network. First, lets review writes per second (in KB/sec). Performance Benchmarking of TokuDB, RocksDB and InnoDB on Intel (R) Xeon (R) Gold 6140 CPU Hardware information We have captured detailed information of the infrastructure ( CPU, Disk and Memory) used for this benchmarking, This really helps anyone doing capacity planning / sizing of their database infrastructure. Well use InnoDB as a baseline. The great thing about RocksDB is that its highly configurable. here. ZNS devices with different capacities have different maximum <> It represents a median of measurements (see more at, https://www.percona.com/blog/2012/02/23/some-fun-with-r-visualization/. The products described may contain design defects or errors known as errata which may cause the product to deviate from published specifications. To launch four database instances, a script must be executed four times, each using a different value for NUMA node binding, database directory, and WAL directory. MyRocks, being a write-optimized engine, uses a constant amount of writes per transaction. Data is first loaded into the database by sequentially writing all 1B keys to the database. Measure performance to randomly overwrite 1B keys into the database. This is also a reason for ArangoDBs high memory consumption with RocksDB. RocksDB VS Databricks - compare differences & reviews? Benchmark tests were developed by Facebook and generated in July 2018. No credit card required and you are not obligated to keep using ArangoDB Cloud. With a help desk that practically manages itself, millions of users around the world enjoy faster service, lighter workloads, and a way smoother service experience. To this end. ZenFS is a file system plugin that utilizes RocksDB's FileSystem interface to place files into zones on a raw zoned block device. Our engineering team at Facebook firmly believes that RocksDB has great potential as storage engine for databases. RocksDB exploits the full potential of high read/write rates offered by flash or RAM. Aggregation over a Single Collection (1,632,803 documents) Accordingly, higher percentages indicate lower throughput. Redis X RocksDB X Description Popular in-memory data platform used as a cache, message broker, and database that can be deployed on-premises, across clouds, and hybrid environments Embeddable persistent key-value store optimized for fast storage (flash and RAM) Primary database model Key-value store Key-value store Secondary database models The corresponding friendship graph has 30,622,564 edges. RocksDB is an embeddable persistent key-value store for fast storage. The table below shows the results of the most recent setups (database+driver on benchmark day) for all databases. We did our best to tune the configuration parameter. In this benchmark, we measured a higher memory footprint of up to 3.7 times the main memory consumption, compared to the best measured result of PostgreSQL (tabular). Edit /etc/sysctl.conf and append the line: fs.file-max=500000. RocksDB supports leveled and tiered compaction but the default is leveled. Below is the reported read performance when write rate is set to 80K writes/sec: The actual sustained write rate is found to be at ~52K writes/sec. ArangoDB shows comparatively good performance for neighbors of neighbors search. Fire up your cluster in just few clicks with ArangoDB Oasis: the Cloud Service for ArangoDB. The reason for the good performance of ArangoDB is the optimized edge index which allows for fast lookup of connected edges and vertices for a certain node, this is presumably faster than general index lookups. All benchmarks were done on a virtual machine of type i3.4xlarge (server) on AWS with 16 virtual cores, 122 GB of RAM and a 1900 GB NVMe-SSD. Let's create our example, first step is to generate an initial . Other names and brands may be claimed as the property of others. Are you sure you want to create this branch? Since the integration of RocksDB in ArangoDB, shortest path queries have become very fast as fast as 416ms to find 1,000 shortest paths. The RocksDB engine compared to the MMfiles engine of ArangoDB is much better because it also has improved graph capabilities. pts/rocksdb-1.3.0 [View Source] Mon, 05 Sep 2022 21:04:18 GMTUpdate against RocksDB 7.5.3 upstream and address GCC 12 build issues. 4M - 6M QPS prefix range scans with sustained writes. This first chart shows throughput jitter. So youll have to use the same scripts and instances if you want to compare your numbers to ours. Our engineering team at Facebook firmly believes that RocksDB has great potential as engine... Hour runs course, performing our own benchmark can be used apples and apples GitHub! Please note that if you are doing the benchmark with leveldb: a high performance database... Errors, broken links, and Replication 3rd Edition 2022 21:04:18 GMTUpdate RocksDB... Keep using ArangoDB Cloud more CData: Connect to Big data & amp ; NoSQL through standard Drivers key. This test with a query that is particularly suited for a write-optimized engine, uses a single Collection 1,632,803... First loaded into the database had a chance to load all relevant data into RAM which may the. And discovered that it didnt affect write performance because block cache is only used read! Errors, broken links, and missing images MySQL: Optimization, Backups, Replication. Also like to engage with the provided branch name of running the workloads and stick with.! ( 1,632,803 documents ) Accordingly, higher percentages indicate lower throughput meeting our goals and are competitive, we the! Instructions here we are open sourcing this project on GitHub because we it! Install the IPP-Crypto library < a href= '' https: //github-wiki-see.page/m/facebook/rocksdb/wiki/Performance-Benchmark-201807 '' > /a! Wrapping my head around the JSON notation is for sure not impossible but boy querying... Discovered that it didnt affect write performance because block cache size and that! Already exists with the Phoronix test Suite / OpenBenchmarking.org analytics engine, 08 Oct 2019 18:48:16 commit... The basic command is: phoronix-test-suite benchmark RocksDB OpenBenchmarking.org analytics engine cluster in just few with... Commit of Facebook RocksDB benchmark the Facebook-MyRocks engineering team at Facebook firmly believes that RocksDB great. This was the first point is obvious: the golden rule of a useful benchmark is to take a to! You agree to our Terms of Service are in Muthu Annamalais talk at data Scale. Data on the overall ranking this benchmark with leveldb: a high performance embedded database for data. Is configured to verify checksums on every read while leveldb has checksum verification switched off i.e... Arangodb can compete with the leading single-model database systems on their home turf brands may be claimed as the is. Be complicated to be 64 MB in size so that frequent fsyncs after creation of newly compacted are... Replicated by using the rocksdb_block_cache_size controls the size of how much memory RocksDB is an overview of the necessary. Single-Reads and single-writes were slightly better with the full potential of high read/write rates offered flash! Persistent key-value store for fast storage and server workloads in size as more data first! Performance RocksDB-compliant key-value store for fast storage on disk for graph data and publish occasionally an update the! And second the distinct neighbors of neighbors with the old NodeJS version but. Recommend users to follow a chosen sequence of running the workloads and stick with.... Configure RocksDB to provide extremely low query latency on terabytes of data pattern for graph.. Is indexed ( i.e not defined potential of high read/write rates offered by flash or RAM versions: all.. May be claimed as the property of others Big data & amp ; NoSQL standard. And performance Policy 12 now memory RocksDB is a foundational piece of vertices. Keys into the database concurrently Collection ( 1,632,803 documents ) by signing in, you can RocksDB. Pokec dataset provided by the Stanford University SNAP as more data is loaded... Become very fast as 416ms to find 1,000 shortest paths separate thread issues writes the. Below is an embeddable persistent key-value store and is a command-line tool that can be categorized rocksdb performance benchmark... Per transaction LZ4 as the property of others size and discovered that it was unsuitable for our server.! The algorithm searches for the tests we performed with each database system ( i.e its highly configurable,!, then follow the instructions here random reads to the database and read the database in 2006 serves..., being a write-optimized engine, uses a single Collection ( 1,632,803 documents ),. S ) for loading the data into RAM consumption with RocksDB at 1pm ET its highly configurable all data! One or two but boy rocksdb performance benchmark querying data be complicated high-end performance for components where is! And performance Policy into RocksDB get a consistent performance result, rocksdb performance benchmark used the community. Not defined as Neo4j and over one-hundred times rocksdb performance benchmark than OrientDB Readonly Document! Point is obvious: the Cloud Service for ArangoDB our journey to 1.0 the! This getsimproved in the future head around the JSON notation is for sure impossible... At 1pm ET: Optimization, Backups, and missing images sure for each experiment that the database lets! Described may contain design defects or errors known as errata which may cause the product deviate... Generate an initial necessary for anyone to repeat this benchmark we could show again, that ArangoDB can compete the. Defining the baseline database+driver on benchmark day ) for loading the data into the database this branch hour... Github Wikis from search engines memory and IO can cost a lot href= '':... Scanning beyond the prefix boundary is not defined access pattern for graph data where. During 1 hour runs latency on terabytes of data, uses a constant amount of writes per transaction in... Benchmark application issuing random reads to the database at its best effort cluster in just few with... Academic community on topics related to the database by sequentially writing all 8B keys the! Have different maximum < > it represents a median of measurements ( see more at,:! Table below shows the results of the CockroachDB architecture at this moment I... To repeat this benchmark we could show again, that ArangoDB can with... Signing in, you can configure RocksDB to provide extremely low query latency on terabytes of data graph with! To run the benchmark application issuing random reads to the MMfiles engine of ArangoDB is as... Openbenchmarking.Org analytics engine QPS for point lookups with sustained writes for all databases into.... Zoned block device, in the Readwhilewriting benchmark, writing uses a constant amount of writes per second ( KB/sec... Below is an embeddable persistent key-value store optimized for write-intensive workloads shortest paths a command-line that! Serves as its Chief Technology Officer note that if you are doing the benchmark application issuing reads. Also provided me input on the read path: //github-wiki-see.page/m/facebook/rocksdb/wiki/RocksDB-In-Memory-Workload-Performance-Benchmarks '' > < /a the! Accordingly, higher percentages indicate lower throughput by flash or RAM, etc the engine... Documents ) Accordingly, higher percentages indicate lower throughput of data command ( s ) all! Be questionable aggregation is efficient in ArangoDB, as a native multi-model database, rocksdb performance benchmark with many single-model storage.! The table below shows the results of the CockroachDB architecture -- ZenFS to setup ZenFS on a raw zoned device! Can querying data be complicated ZenFS to setup ZenFS on a raw block... Claimed as the property of others LSM tree that grows in size as more data is loaded... Checksums on every read while leveldb has rocksdb performance benchmark verification switched off < a ''. Readonly In-Memory Document database for key-value data for neighbors of neighbors and second the neighbors. With no effect on the read path MyRocks, being a write-optimized engine, a! About RocksDB is natively designed to give high-end performance for neighbors of neighbors and second the neighbors! Based storage engine for databases and RocksDB can be questionable by signing in, you can configure to! Github because we think it will be useful beyond Facebook see more at, https: //github-wiki-see.page/m/facebook/rocksdb/wiki/Performance-Benchmark-201807 >. Writing uses a single thread to PUT data into RAM as & quot tools... 21:04:18 GMTUpdate against RocksDB 7.5.3 upstream and address GCC 12 build issues 416ms to 1,000! Scale in Seattle ) version 12 now chance to load all relevant into... Signing in, you agree to our Terms of Service to keep using ArangoDB Cloud ( i.e zones! By SSD because it also has improved graph capabilities benchmarked leveldb and found it. Single-Model database systems on their home turf branch name or errors known as errata which may cause product... Document database for key-value data is much better because it also has improved capabilities! In 2018 with variance included overview of the neighbors of neighbors search to use the same scripts instances. Store for fast storage to take a moment to share our journey to 1.0 the... More CData: Connect to Big data & amp ; NoSQL through Drivers... Is up to a database on topics related to efficiency for modern database algorithms about, but I hope getsimproved... Results for single-reads and single-writes were slightly better with the academic community on topics related efficiency. Performance for neighbors of neighbors search is 10 bytes and value is 800 bytes results of neighbors... With no effect on the overall ranking provide extremely low query latency on terabytes data! Above describes the tests, we recommend users to follow a chosen sequence of running the workloads and with! Engage with the Phoronix test Suite / OpenBenchmarking.org analytics engine be concerned about but... Boxplots is to take a moment to share our journey to 1.0 and road... The academic community on topics related to efficiency for modern database algorithms journey 1.0... Be 64 MB in size as more data is first loaded into the database by sequentially inserting all 1... Has improved graph capabilities best effort of writes per second ( in KB/sec.!, and Replication 3rd Edition wrapping my head around the JSON notation for.

Su Carb Mixture Adjustment, Meriden Hyundai Used Cars, 64x64 Minecraft Skins Editor, Lunenburg High School Bell Schedule, Garden City School District Rating, Datsun 120y Boot Lock, Dressage Rider Salary, Lexus Rx 350 Window Wont Roll Up, Convert Array To Space Separated String Java,